Rachel Reeves has announced plans to scrap the Lifetime ISA (LISA) due to widespread dissatisfaction over hefty withdrawal penalties that have burdened savers with charges exceeding £10,000. The Treasury is set to replace the LISA with a new product called the First Time Buyer ISA (FTB ISA), targeted exclusively at individuals over 18 who intend to purchase their first home.
In a recent government consultation, officials acknowledged that the Lifetime ISA “is not working well for many” savers, primarily because of a 25% penalty on withdrawals made for unauthorized purposes or properties exceeding the price cap. This punitive charge has discouraged many from using the LISA’s benefits, limiting access to crucial support for homeownership.
Freedom of Information Act requests reveal some account holders have faced penalty fees as high as £10,600, spotlighting the urgent need for reform. The Treasury admitted this withdrawal charge “put off some savers,” prompting the decision to eliminate it under the new plan.
READ MORE: Peaky Blinders Creator Announces Ambitious Vision for Birmingham’s Film and TV Industry
Financial experts have weighed in on the proposed changes. Rachael Griffin, tax and financial planning expert at Quilter, noted that the LISA’s house price cap of £450,000, unchanged since 2017, no longer aligns with today’s market — particularly in London and the South East. This mismatch has penalized diligent savers unable to use their LISA for suitable properties. Griffin criticized that the new FTB ISA does not yet address this issue, suggesting that revised, more realistic caps are urgently needed.
Brian Byrnes, director of personal finance at Moneybox, expressed concerns that paying bonuses only at the point of purchase might reduce the overall benefit for savers, potentially extending the time first-time buyers need to save for a deposit. He described the government’s proposal as “more complicated, more restrictive, and potentially less valuable” compared to existing options.
Byrnes emphasized support for efforts to help first-time buyers but argued that improving the current Lifetime ISA would be more beneficial than replacing it with a seemingly inferior alternative.
Meanwhile, political speculation is rife that Reeves may step down as Chancellor if Andy Burnham replaces Sir Keir Starmer as Prime Minister, with Ed Miliband rumored as a potential replacement.